-
Paul Nash
Fantasy, 1932Pencil and watercolour on paper35.6 x 55.9 cm
14 x 22 inCopyright The ArtistThis watercolour painting is a larger, autograph version of one of Paul Nash’s drawings to accompany The Garden of Cyprus by the seventeenth-century physician and writer Sir Thomas Browne. Nash...This watercolour painting is a larger, autograph version of one of Paul Nash’s drawings to accompany The Garden of Cyprus by the seventeenth-century physician and writer Sir Thomas Browne. Nash admired Browne’s writing and when Cassell & Co. approached him with a commission to illustrate a text, he chose The Garden of Cyrus and Urne Buriall. He made thirty ‘drawings’ for a lavish edition which was published in 1932. The drawings were printed by the Curwen Press using monochrome collotype hand-tinted by watercolour with the aid of stencils. According to the critic Anthony Bertram, ‘in his illustrations to these two books the essentially symbolic character of [Nash’s] work finally emerges and all his symbols are present or foreshadowed.’
In the Outline for his autobiography, Nash wrote: ‘Making the designs for Urne Burial. Research and contemplation. The series slowly unfolds.’ The circumstances and significance of Cassell’s commission were described in more detail by Paul Nash’s wife, Margaret, in her memoirs:
[…] it became an extremely important special edition, for which Paul carried out 32 of his most important and imaginative designs. […] the whole book was a joy to him while he worked on it and helped to liberate his imagination and encourage the highly poetic vision which permeated his early work and a great deal of his subsequent paintings.
Only Nash’s full-page illustrations in the book were afforded titles. The drawing that relates to Fantasy appeared in chapter IV on page 112. It interrupts this passage:
And this is also the law of reflexion in moved bodies and sounds, which though not made by decussation, observe the rule of equality between incidence and reflexion; whereby whispering places are framed by Ellipticall arches laid side-wise; where the voice being delivered at the focus of one extremity, observing an equality unto the angle of incidence, it will reflect unto the focus of the other end, and so escape the ears of the standers in the middle.
Nash’s ‘drawings’ were a personal response to Browne’s text, and only occasionally do they make a literal translation of Browne’s imagery. In the case of Fantasy, Nash extracted Browne’s reference to ‘Ellipticall arches laid side-wise’ and realised them as a sequence of barrel vaults supported by Corinthian columns. This enclosed architectural chamber stands to one side of an open landscape in which the moon emits a concentrated beam. This straight, plank-like ray of light strikes the ground where a tree trunk has fallen. The moon in the sky may be a literal picturing of Browne’s text on the facing page, which discusses the existence of the human body and soul:
[…] By the circle implying the uniform motion of the first Orb, and by the right lines, the planetical and various motions within it. And this also with application unto the soul of man, which hath a double aspect, one right, whereby it beholdeth the body, and objects without; another circular and reciprocal, whereby it beholdeth it self. The circle declaring the motion of the indivisible soul, simple, according to the divinity of its nature, and returning into it self; the right lines respecting the motion pertaining unto sense, and vegetation, and the central decussation, the wondrous connexion of the severall faculties conjointly in one substance.
More literally, the celestial body and its emission of light may relate to a passage on the preceding page in which Browne described an optical effect. Of the ‘Laws of direct Vision’ and ‘the reflected rayes of sight’, he observed that:
[…] making the angle of incidence equal to that of reflexion, the visual raye returneth Quincuncially, and after the form of a V, and the line of reflexion being continued unto the place of vision, there ariseth a semi-decussation, which makes the object seen in a perpendicular unto it self, and as farre below the reflectent, as it is from it above; observable in the Sun and Moon beheld in water.
This phenomenon is known in modern-day optics as glittering light. Rather than being reflected as a discrete orb, the sun or moon instead produces in water a column of light. Nash depicted glittering light in another drawing for Thomas Browne, The Quincunx Artificially Considered, and later painted the same effect on the Mediterranean when he stayed at Nice in 1934. Two paintings — View Я (Rugby Museum & Art Gallery) and View Ƨ (Cartwright Hall Art Gallery, Bradford) — show the view from Nash’s balcony in the Hotel des Princes, and the same visit occasioned a watercolour, Souvenir of Nice (Private Collection), in which the trunk of a palm tree is woven into the background of the glittering sea by a criss-cross pattern of quincunxes just as Thomas Browne described four centuries earlier.
The significance of Nash’s designs for Urne Buriall and The Garden of Cyrus is suggested by his decision, once the book was complete, to make from them six larger watercolours and three oil paintings. Fantasy is one of these, while another watercolour — Mansions of the Dead — was owned by the poet and impresario Edward James (1907–1984) and later purchased by the Tate Gallery in 1981.
The first documented owner of Fantasy was Gwendolyn, Lady Herbert (née Quilter). She loaned the picture along with an oil painting, Winter Landscape – Iver Heath, to Nash’s Venice Biennale display in 1938, and she owned other works of British modern art such as The Gypsy at her toilet (1924) by Mark Gertler. Her husband was the notable humourist Sir A. P. Herbert, a frequent contributor to Punch magazine, who served as M.P. for Oxford University between 1935 and 1950. Fantasy was purchased from her sale at Christie’s in 1953 by Dr H. P. (Harold Paine) Widdup (1899–1962), a Surgeon Commander in the Royal Navy and a prolific collector of modern British art. He bequeathed 366 artworks to the Contemporary Art Society, which were subsequently donated many to British and overseas museums and galleries. Fantasy was one of many works sold from Widdup’s collection by the Redfern Gallery, London, in 1963 and 1964. Besides this he owned others by Paul Nash including Romney Marsh (1921) [Causey 325]. Fantasy was bought from Redfern by R. F. Shaw-Kennedy, a reserve officer in the Territorial Army until 1960 who held the rank of Lieutenant Colonel. Known as ‘Ronnie’ to his friends, he was subsequently elected as a Conservative councillor, serving first in Berkeley Ward between 1962 and 1964, and later for Regent Street ward from 1964 until his resignation in 1971. He formed a small art collection in the ’fifities and ’sixties that included pictures by Nash, Walter Sickert, Dante Gabriel Rossetti and Philip Wilson Steer. Fantasy was auctioned in Shaw-Kennedy’s sale at Christie’s in 1973, where it was purchased by ‘Benidor’. It came to market again in 2025, when it was acquired from the previous owner by Piano Nobile.Provenance
Lady Herbert
At Christie's, London, 23 Dec. 1953
Dr H. P. Widdup
The Redfern Gallery, London, 1963
R. Shaw-Kennedy
At Christie's, London, 13 July 1973, lot 273 (listed as 'Equinox')
Benidor
Private Collection
Piano Nobile, London
Exhibitions
London, The Leicester Galleries, Exhibition of Water-Colour Drawings by Paul Nash, Nov. 1932, no. 2
Venice, XV Biennale, Exhibition of British Section, June 1938, no. 18Leeds, Leeds City Art Gallery and Temple Newsam, Exhibition of Paintings, Sculpture and Drawings by Paul Nash and Barbara Hepworth, April – June 1943, no. 51
London, Redfern Gallery, French and English Drawings and Water-colours, 26 Feb. – 22 March 1963, no. 325 (listed as 'Equinox')
London, Redfern Gallery, Twentieth Century French and English Paintings, Drawings, Watercolours, 17 June – 25 Sept. 1964, no. 507 (listed as 'The Equinox')
Literature
John Armstrong, 'Watercolours by Paul Nash at the Leicester Galleries', Weekend Review, 5 Nov. 1932, p. 542
20th Century French and English Drawings and Watercolours, exh. cat., Redfern Gallery, 1963, no. 325, n.p. (illus.)
Andrew Causey, Paul Nash, Clarendon Press, 1980, no. 752, p. 422