William Coldstream
Sonia Brownell, 1939
Oil on canvas
25.4 x 20.3 cm
10 x 8 in
10 x 8 in
Copyright The Artist
This painting of Sonia Brownell (1918–1980) testifies to an intimate relationship between the artist and sitter. Later in life William Coldstream remembered that it was made ‘just before and just...
This painting of Sonia Brownell (1918–1980) testifies to an intimate relationship between the artist and sitter. Later in life William Coldstream remembered that it was made ‘just before and just after the beginning of the war’, and it was then, as his marriage was ending, that he ‘fell very much in love with her’. Their affair, ‘peripatetic as well as clandestine, conducted at snatched meetings’, has been described by Brownell’s friend and biographer Hilary Spurling. It began in autumn 1939 and was ‘more or less over’ by spring 1941. They met through the milieu of artists and wives around the Euston Road School, co-founded by Coldstream, Victor Pasmore and Claude Rogers, and only when she went to work for the new cultural magazine Horizon did her interest wane. As Spurling wrote, ‘their affair could not long survive this new enchantment.’ The conclusion of their intimacy upset Coldstream, and he wrote to a friend as the affair dwindled: ‘I have the very greatest difficulty in doing any work whatsoever […]. I long all the time to see Sonia’. ‘This small canvas is painted with a lyrical touch, in spite of traces of Euston Road-style measurements and vertical brush strokes, and has an unusual spontaneity’, wrote the art historian Bruce Laughton. Spurling dwelt on the painting’s psychological qualities: ‘She looks like one of Renoir’s plum, tousled, pink-flushed girls, except that her stare is both more provocative and more guarded.’
In part owing to her fair looks and her residence near the School, Brownell was sometimes saluted as the ‘Euston Road Venus’. Spurling describes this epithet as both flattering and ironic, not least as she ‘never took her clothes off to pose for the life class in the nude’. Brownell left an impression upon her friends of the period, and the poet Stephen Spender described her: ‘round Renoir face, limpid eyes, cupid mouth, fair hair, a bit pale perhaps. She had a look of someone always struggling to go beyond herself’. She enjoyed an extended period as secretary at Horizon. After a brief part-time role in 1941, she worked there from 1945 until 1949 during which she held the venture together amid the frequent absences of its editor Cyril Connolly. She married George Orwell in 1949, and after his death the following year she managed his literary estate. She latterly worked for the publisher John Lehmann, co-edited the journal Art and Literature in 1964–65, and with Ian Angus edited The Collected Essays, Journalism and Letters of George Orwell (1968, Secker & Warburg).
Besides this portrait, Brownell was depicted elsewhere by Coldstream and his contemporaries. She is said to be one of those women, mid-conversation, seated on a bench, in Claude Rogers’s painting The Broad Walk, Regent’s Park. Coldstream made a drawing of her asleep, and she sat again for an unfinished painting that was likely begun in 1940 or 1941. She became friends with the wife of Coldstream’s confidant Dr Jack Rake, and while they were staying at the Rakes’ Oxfordshire cottage she sat for both men who painted her side-by-side.
Sonia Brownell was among the many literary people that appear in Coldstream’s work of this period. He became acquainted with the poet W. H. Auden when they worked together at the General Post Office in the mid-thirties. Auden sat for Coldstream in 1937 (University of Texas at Austin), the year he returned to his career as a painter, and that year he also portrayed several other literary celebrities among his friends including Christopher Isherwood, Louis MacNeice and Stephen Spender. More broadly he also painted Auden’s mother and J. B. Priestley’s daughter Barbara. It is telling of Coldstream’s literary orbit that this painting of Sonia Brownell was first owned by the playwright J. B. Priestley, whose second wife Jane Wyndham Lewis attended the Euston Road School.
The careful, deliberate application of paint in feathered cross-hatching is characteristic of Coldstream’s practice at the time. His friend Lawrence Gowing described the style in 1962: ‘The straight brush strokes […] make a parallel hatching. They form a grid against which the information registers as if by an automatic magic. As the system becomes more and more comprehensive in succeeding pictures they cross and recross, drawing the web this way and that to catch what it will.’ Gowing’s emphasis was upon the impartiality of Coldstream’s gaze. He went on to explain the process of measuring that was central to Coldstream’s method: ‘The brush-handle is held rigid at a long and wiry arm’s length; the thumb nail creeps up and down it, capturing an exact distance (or rather, an exact angle in the visual cone, as if vision itself were palpable) and comparing it with another, and still another, and so on in an endless process. The measurements are comparative.’ In short, Coldstream loaded his every mark with observation, and he strove to mark his observations as objectively as his process allowed.
Appendix
Excerpt from Peter T. J. Rumley, William Coldstream: Catalogue Raisonné, Sansom & Co., 2018, p. 53
Sonia Brownell, known as the ‘Euston Road Venus’, a satellite of the Euston Road School and literary men, was initially painted by Coldstream in the studio of the School of Painting and Drawing, 314/16 Euston Road, during the summer of 1937. The picture was completed at 8 Fitzroy Street, in the studio that belonged to Vanessa Bell and at one time belonged to Sickert. She worked for John Lehmann on the book-format periodical New Writing and with Cyril Connolly on the cultural magazine Horizon. John Lehmann commented:
Her daring, gay, cynical intelligence and insatiable appetite for knowing everything about the literary world: her revolt against a convent upbringing seemed to provide her life in those days with a kind of inexhaustible rocket fuel.
The picture was completed shortly before Coldstream and Sonia stayed with Rodrigo and Elinor Moynihan at their country retreat, Monksbury, Little Hallingbury, near Sawbridgeworth, Hertfordshire, in the autumn. Sonia Brownell married the writer George Orwell in 1949.
In part owing to her fair looks and her residence near the School, Brownell was sometimes saluted as the ‘Euston Road Venus’. Spurling describes this epithet as both flattering and ironic, not least as she ‘never took her clothes off to pose for the life class in the nude’. Brownell left an impression upon her friends of the period, and the poet Stephen Spender described her: ‘round Renoir face, limpid eyes, cupid mouth, fair hair, a bit pale perhaps. She had a look of someone always struggling to go beyond herself’. She enjoyed an extended period as secretary at Horizon. After a brief part-time role in 1941, she worked there from 1945 until 1949 during which she held the venture together amid the frequent absences of its editor Cyril Connolly. She married George Orwell in 1949, and after his death the following year she managed his literary estate. She latterly worked for the publisher John Lehmann, co-edited the journal Art and Literature in 1964–65, and with Ian Angus edited The Collected Essays, Journalism and Letters of George Orwell (1968, Secker & Warburg).
Besides this portrait, Brownell was depicted elsewhere by Coldstream and his contemporaries. She is said to be one of those women, mid-conversation, seated on a bench, in Claude Rogers’s painting The Broad Walk, Regent’s Park. Coldstream made a drawing of her asleep, and she sat again for an unfinished painting that was likely begun in 1940 or 1941. She became friends with the wife of Coldstream’s confidant Dr Jack Rake, and while they were staying at the Rakes’ Oxfordshire cottage she sat for both men who painted her side-by-side.
Sonia Brownell was among the many literary people that appear in Coldstream’s work of this period. He became acquainted with the poet W. H. Auden when they worked together at the General Post Office in the mid-thirties. Auden sat for Coldstream in 1937 (University of Texas at Austin), the year he returned to his career as a painter, and that year he also portrayed several other literary celebrities among his friends including Christopher Isherwood, Louis MacNeice and Stephen Spender. More broadly he also painted Auden’s mother and J. B. Priestley’s daughter Barbara. It is telling of Coldstream’s literary orbit that this painting of Sonia Brownell was first owned by the playwright J. B. Priestley, whose second wife Jane Wyndham Lewis attended the Euston Road School.
The careful, deliberate application of paint in feathered cross-hatching is characteristic of Coldstream’s practice at the time. His friend Lawrence Gowing described the style in 1962: ‘The straight brush strokes […] make a parallel hatching. They form a grid against which the information registers as if by an automatic magic. As the system becomes more and more comprehensive in succeeding pictures they cross and recross, drawing the web this way and that to catch what it will.’ Gowing’s emphasis was upon the impartiality of Coldstream’s gaze. He went on to explain the process of measuring that was central to Coldstream’s method: ‘The brush-handle is held rigid at a long and wiry arm’s length; the thumb nail creeps up and down it, capturing an exact distance (or rather, an exact angle in the visual cone, as if vision itself were palpable) and comparing it with another, and still another, and so on in an endless process. The measurements are comparative.’ In short, Coldstream loaded his every mark with observation, and he strove to mark his observations as objectively as his process allowed.
Appendix
Excerpt from Peter T. J. Rumley, William Coldstream: Catalogue Raisonné, Sansom & Co., 2018, p. 53
Sonia Brownell, known as the ‘Euston Road Venus’, a satellite of the Euston Road School and literary men, was initially painted by Coldstream in the studio of the School of Painting and Drawing, 314/16 Euston Road, during the summer of 1937. The picture was completed at 8 Fitzroy Street, in the studio that belonged to Vanessa Bell and at one time belonged to Sickert. She worked for John Lehmann on the book-format periodical New Writing and with Cyril Connolly on the cultural magazine Horizon. John Lehmann commented:
Her daring, gay, cynical intelligence and insatiable appetite for knowing everything about the literary world: her revolt against a convent upbringing seemed to provide her life in those days with a kind of inexhaustible rocket fuel.
The picture was completed shortly before Coldstream and Sonia stayed with Rodrigo and Elinor Moynihan at their country retreat, Monksbury, Little Hallingbury, near Sawbridgeworth, Hertfordshire, in the autumn. Sonia Brownell married the writer George Orwell in 1949.
Provenance
J. B. PriestleyMrs D. A. Bannerman
Dudley Bailey, and by descent
Piano Nobile, London
Exhibitions
Arts Council of Great Britain, William Coldstream, 1962, no. 27, touring to Camberwell, South London Art Gallery, 27 April – 26 May; Leeds, The University, 9 – 30 June; Bristol, City Art Gallery, 7 – 28 July; Swansea, Glyn Vivian Art Gallery, 4 – 25 Aug.; Southampton, City Art Gallery, 1 – 22 Sept.; and Birmingham, City Museum and Art Gallery, 29 Sept. – 20 Oct.London, Tate Gallery, The Paintings of William Coldstream 1908–1987, 17 Oct. 1990 – 6 Jan. 1991, no. 20
Literature
The Paintings of William Coldstream 1908–1987, exh. cat., Tate Gallery, 1990, no. 20, p. 56 (col. illus.)Hilary Spurling, The Girl from the Fiction Department, Hamish Hamilton, 2002, pp. 29, 38 (illus.)
Bruce Laughton, William Coldstream, Yale University Press, 2004, p. 64, fig. 32 (illus.)
Peter T. J. Rumley, William Coldstream: Catalogue Raisonné, Sansom & Co., 2018, no. 47, p. 53 (col. illus.)
Catherine Coldstream, ed., William Coldstream Remembered: Portraits of a Painter, Sansom & Company, 2025, pp. 193–194, fig. 33.2 (col. illus.)
1
of
7